Thursday, October 9, 2025
Advertise with us
Support us
Write for us
No Result
View All Result
claws
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
CLAWS
No Result
View All Result
Home External Publications

Defence Diaries: Operation Sindoor and Beyond – Recognition Is a Tribute, Not a Political Tool | Opinion

Ashu MaanbyAshu Maan
August 16, 2025
in External Publications
A A
0
Post Views: 59

This article was first published at: https://newsable.asianetnews.com/india/defence-diaries-operation-sindoor-recognition-is-a-tribute-not-a-political-tool-articleshow-0r81fhn

Following the release of a promotional video showing celebrated actor and quiz show host Amitabh Bachchan interacting with three women officers of the Indian military, social media has been rife with a new debate.

On X, formerly Twitter, the appearance of the three officers— Indian Army’s Colonel Sofiya Qureshi, Indian Air Force’s Wing Commander Vyomika Singh, and Indian Navy’s Commander Prerna Deosthalee— on popular quiz show, Kaun Banega Crorepati (KBC), has led to critics making allegations of “PR for politics”. They have voiced concerns, even if misplaced, that this visibility amounts to political publicity or exploitation of patriotism for partisan gains.

Many have objected to the use of military uniforms and public faces of Operation Sindoor, insinuating that this is a new practice, and a new low.

But these comments do not take into account facts and nuances. Here’s an breakdown of the discourse and the facts that have been overshadowed by misplaced criticism.

Publicity vs Recognition: A Key Difference

First, it is crucial to distinguish between publicity and recognition. Publicity is typically sought by politicians and brands; recognition, on the other hand, is the rightful acknowledgment of heroes.

The men and women who sport the uniform of the Indian Armed Forces do not seek out the spotlight. Instead, they earn it through immense sacrifice, discipline, and dedication. It must be understood that recognition of their achievements is not an act of political publicity but a tribute to their valour and service.

In fact, one would argue recognition is crucial to maintaining morale of the forces.

Military Personnel In Uniform On TV Is Not New

Now, on to addressing those who feel as though there is some shift in policy that has, for the first time, allowed military personnel onto a public infotainment program.

Note that serving personnel, including recipients of the Param Vir Chakra and other gallantry awards, have appeared on similar platforms in the past. Their stories of extraordinary bravery have been shared widely, educating the public and inspiring generations. Thus, the three women officers appearing on KBC is not unprecedented in any way.

If anything, it is a continuation of honouring armed forces personnel who have made extraordinary contributions to national security.

Building Civil-Military Communication

Regarding the public-facing part, it is important to understand that communicating the successes of recent operations like Operation Sindoor to the public is crucial. It is in the interest of transparency and awareness.

Both of those are important by themselves, but are also the key to foster national pride and a better understanding of the challenges the military overcomes.

It is for this very reason that the military has established protocols on when its personnel can make public appearances while in uniform.

Showcasing Nari Shakti In The Military

Lastly, the Indian Army, both in action and spirit, does not distinguish between genders. Whether the officers are men or women, their courage and commitment are equally respected and celebrated. Highlighting women officers alongside their male counterparts reflects the progressive ethos of the armed forces and inspires young women across the nation to consider a career in the military.

Recognition of our armed forces’ achievements should never be misconstrued as political posturing. It is simply a deserved homage to those who serve, protect, and inspire us every day.

Previous Post

CLAWS Russia Newsletter | 01 – 15 August 2025

Next Post

CLAWS USA Newsletter | 01 – 15 August 2025

Ashu Maan

Ashu Maan

Ashu Maan is an Associate Fellow at the Centre for Land Warfare Studies. He was awarded the VCOAS Commendation card on Army Day 2025. He is currently pursuing his PhD from Amity University, Noida in Defence and Strategic Studies. He has previously worked with Institute of Chinese Studies. He has also contributed a chapter on “Denuclearization of North Korea” in the book titled Drifts and Dynamics: Russia’s Ukraine War and Northeast Asia. His research includes India-China territorial dispute, the Great Power Rivalry between the United States and China, and China’s Foreign Policy.

Next Post
CLAWS USA Newsletter | 01 – 15 July 2025

CLAWS USA Newsletter | 01 - 15 August 2025

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support Us Donate Now

Web Updates

IIFOMAS | CLAWS | Essay Competition

CLAWS MAHE PHD PGME CALL FOR ADMISSIONS: PHD BATCH- 8: JAN 2026

Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

Guidelines to Publish with CLAWS

Summer Internship Capsule 2025

Application Form – Study Mtrl for DSSC 2025

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Results | Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competition – 2024

Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

May 23, 2025

Summer Internship Capsule 2025

April 8, 2025
Russia-Ukraine War: Lessons from an Electronic Warfare (EW) Perspective

Russia-Ukraine War: Lessons from an Electronic Warfare (EW) Perspective

May 31, 2025
From Sword Clashes to Drone Strikes: A History of Changing Battlefields

From Sword Clashes to Drone Strikes: A History of Changing Battlefields

July 31, 2025
From Sword Clashes to Drone Strikes: A History of Changing Battlefields

From Sword Clashes to Drone Strikes: A History of Changing Battlefields

16
The Arakan Army and Its Impact on India: Rising Tensions Along the Eastern Frontier 

The Arakan Army and Its Impact on India: Rising Tensions Along the Eastern Frontier 

9
Bill of Material (BOM), Vulnerability for Supply Chain Attacks

Bill of Material (BOM), Vulnerability for Supply Chain Attacks

4
At the Edge of Stability: India’s Options amid Myanmar’s Unfolding Crisis

At the Edge of Stability: India’s Options amid Myanmar’s Unfolding Crisis

3
From Euro-Atlantic to Eurasia: Moscow’s Bid for a New Security Order

From Euro-Atlantic to Eurasia: Moscow’s Bid for a New Security Order

October 8, 2025
IIFOMAS | CLAWS | Essay Competition

IIFOMAS | CLAWS | Essay Competition

October 7, 2025
China’s South Asia Play: Dragon In The Backyard 🇨🇳 | CLAWS Junior League, Ep 4

China’s South Asia Play: Dragon In The Backyard 🇨🇳 | CLAWS Junior League, Ep 4

October 6, 2025
India-Afghanistan Ties: Present and Future 

India-Afghanistan Ties: Present and Future 

October 4, 2025

Popular Stories

  • Results | Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competition – 2024

    Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Summer Internship Capsule 2025

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Russia-Ukraine War: Lessons from an Electronic Warfare (EW) Perspective

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • From Sword Clashes to Drone Strikes: A History of Changing Battlefields

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Op Sindoor 2.0: Why & How India Must Prepare for the Next Round?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

About us

CLAWS

The Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS), New Delhi, India is an independent think tank on strategic studies and land warfare. The mandate of CLAWS covers national security issues, conventional military operations and sub-conventional warfare.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Articles
  • Autumn 2019
  • Autumn 2020
  • Books
  • CLAWS Focus
  • CLAWS Journal
  • Essay
  • Events
  • External Publications
  • FMMEC
  • Intern Articles
  • Issue Briefs
  • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
  • Manekshaw Papers
  • Newsletter
  • Round Tables
  • Scholar Warrior
  • Seminars
  • Uncategorized
  • Web Updates
  • Winter 2019
  • YouTube Podcast

Recent News

From Euro-Atlantic to Eurasia: Moscow’s Bid for a New Security Order

From Euro-Atlantic to Eurasia: Moscow’s Bid for a New Security Order

October 8, 2025
IIFOMAS | CLAWS | Essay Competition

IIFOMAS | CLAWS | Essay Competition

October 7, 2025
  • Site Map
  • Tenders
  • Advertise With Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Other Think Tanks

© 2008-2024 Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS).

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2008-2024 Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS).