Tuesday, July 22, 2025
Advertise with us
Support us
Write for us
No Result
View All Result
claws
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
CLAWS
No Result
View All Result
Home Articles

The Government Approves the Post of CDS

Brig. Kuldip SinghbyBrig. Kuldip Singh
December 30, 2019
in Articles
A A
0
Post Views: 130

On December 24, the Government finally approved the post of Chief of Defence Staff (CDS). The Press Information Bureau release[1] (December 24) informed that the CDS will:

  • Be a four-star General with salary and perquisites equivalent to a Service Chief.
  • Head the Department of Military Affairs (DMA), to be created within the Ministry of Defence (MoD) and will function as its Secretary.
  • Also be the Permanent Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee (PCCoSC); a member of Defence Acquisition Council chaired by RM and Defence Planning Committee chaired by NSA; and a Military Adviser to the Nuclear Command Authority (NCA).
  • Act as the Principal Military Adviser to Raksha Mantri (RM) on all tri-Services matters. However, the three Chiefs will continue to advise the RM on matters exclusively concerning their respective Services.
  • Not exercise any military command, including over the three Service Chiefs.

Analysis

Till now, the post of Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee was held by the senior-most Service Chief, who tenanted it for a period ranging from a year to just a few months. The short tenures meant that the advice likely to be rendered during a crisis may be subjective and not institutional. Besides, in a war-like situation, the Chiefs are likely to be pre-occupied steering their own respective Services.  Thus, the post of a CDS addresses a grievous void related to rendering of sagacious, integrated joint forces, strategic advice to the Raksha Mantri and the NSA.

The CDS will simultaneously hold the posts of Secretary (DMA) and the PCCoSC. Thus, when participating as a member in the Defence Acquisition Council (under the RM) and the Defence Planning Committee (under NSA), the CDS would have to reconcile the demand(s) of the Services projected by him as PCCoSC with the requirements/constraints of his own Department in the MoD. Additionally, given that each Service usually over-projects its requirements, there would also be a need to resolve the demands of each Service to meet the overall operational capability required at the national level and within the finite defence budget. There is thus a view that this constant balancing could have been avoided if the existing HQ IDS had been placed under the CDS, moved to the MoD and subsumed as the DMA but with a wider ambit. Nevertheless, it is expected that a CDS, with his long years of experience, and with no forces under his command, should be able to reconcile the conflicting turf requirements of each Service, and yet provide a platform for bridging the civil-military divide.

That said, there are a number of issues of concern.

Presently, the MoD has four main departments, each headed by a Secretary-rank officer. These are (i) Department of Defence Production (DDP) under the Secretary (DP); (ii) Department of Ex-Servicemen’s Welfare (DESW), under the Secretary (ESW); (iii) the Defence Research & Development Organization (DRDO), which is headed by the DRDO’s chief; and (iv) the Department of Defence, headed by Defence Secretary. Assisted by the Director General (Acquisition), Additional Secretaries and Joint Secretaries, the Defence Secretary is also responsible for coordinating the activities of the DDP, DESW and DRDO. In other words, the Secretaries/heads of DDP, DESW and DRDO report through the Defence Secretary, although the Secretary (DDP) also reports directly to the Rajya Raksha Mantri (RRM).

This raises a question: what is the charter of the DMA under the CDS vis-à-vis the Department of Defence under the Defence Secretary? And in case of conflicting views, whose advice on military matters would be binding? Unless clearly delineated, this ambiguity may lead to overlapping responsibilities and inevitable conflicts.

Next: The Vice Chiefs of the Services and the C-in-Cs of Commands (Army/Navy/Air Force) are considered equivalent to the Defence Secretary. The Service Chiefs are senior, with the Cabinet Secretary being deemed as ‘primus inter pares’ (‘first among equals’) with regard to the Service Chiefs. By creating a new Department within the MoD and appointing the CDS as its secretary, the Government has, in a way, perhaps equated the CDS (and by corollary, the Service Chiefs too) as equal to one of the other Secretaries in the MoD, and who report to either the Defence Secretary or RRM. Therefore, unless clarified by the Government, it is possible that the order of precedence as regards the CDS (and the Service Chiefs) versus the Defence Secretary could start to be a subject of dispute and acrimony.

Ideally, the CDS should have been an advisor to the Prime Minister and the CCS/Cabinet, and heading the Defence Planning Committee. In the USA, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (the equivalent of a CDS), is that nation’s highest-ranking military officer and the Principal Military Advisor to the President of the USA, Secretary of Defence and the National Security Council. Even in the UK, the CDS, whose post was downgraded in 1997, yet is the professional head of the British Armed Forces, as well as the most senior uniformed military adviser to the Secretary of State for Defence and importantly, to UK’s Prime Minister[2].

It does therefore seem that instead of appointing a CDS who acts as an Advisor to the Prime Minister of our nation, the Cabinet has in a way, merely made permanent the post of the Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee, and that too in a four-star rank with equivalence to the Service Chiefs. That said, the appointment of a CDS is step in the right direction and it is hoped that this is the first stride in the evolution of a proper CDS.

References:

[1] https://pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetail.aspx?PRID=1597425

[2] Annual Report MoD, UK

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/831728/MOD_Annual_Report_and_Accounts_2018-19_WEB__ERRATUM_CORRECTED_.pdf

Tags: Military StrategyNational Security Strategy
Previous Post

Regional Instability Continues Unabated

Next Post

Old Wine in a New Casket: AFSPA in J&K through the realm of Law.

Brig. Kuldip Singh

Brig. Kuldip Singh

Next Post

Old Wine in a New Casket: AFSPA in J&K through the realm of Law.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support Us Donate Now

Web Updates

List of Shortlisted Officers / Candidates: PhD Batch – 7

Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

Guidelines to Publish with CLAWS

Summer Internship Capsule 2025

Application Form – Study Mtrl for DSSC 2025

[NEW] Application Form for membership for PROMEX (PART B or D)

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

Summer Internship Capsule 2025

April 8, 2025
Results | Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competition – 2024

Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

May 23, 2025
Op Sindoor 2.0: Why & How India Must Prepare for the Next Round?

Op Sindoor 2.0: Why & How India Must Prepare for the Next Round?

May 21, 2025
DefAI: Cyber & AI Frontiers for Defence | The Third Cyber Workshop from CLAWS & HACKTIFY

DefAI: Cyber & AI Frontiers for Defence | The Third Cyber Workshop from CLAWS & HACKTIFY

June 9, 2025

Front Organisations: The Valley’s Homegrown ‘Resistance’ or Pakistan’s Evolving Terrorism Tactics?

2
DefAI: Cyber & AI Frontiers for Defence | The Third Cyber Workshop from CLAWS & HACKTIFY

DefAI: Cyber & AI Frontiers for Defence | The Third Cyber Workshop from CLAWS & HACKTIFY

2
Great Power Rivalry in the Arctic and India

Great Power Rivalry in the Arctic and India

2

Clausewitz, pagers, and the evolving art of supply chain attacks

1
Unmasking LAMEHUG: APT28’s AI-Fuelled Cyber Offensive Against Ukraine

Unmasking LAMEHUG: APT28’s AI-Fuelled Cyber Offensive Against Ukraine

July 21, 2025
Russia Recognises Taliban: A New Era of Cooperation

Russia Recognises Taliban: A New Era of Cooperation

July 16, 2025
CLAWS Pakistan Newsletter | July 01-15, 2025

CLAWS Pakistan Newsletter | July 01-15, 2025

July 16, 2025
CLAWS Cyber Newsletter I 01 – 15 April 2025

CLAWS Cyber Newsletter I 01 – 15 July 2025

July 16, 2025

Popular Stories

  • Summer Internship Capsule 2025

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Field Marshal Manekshaw Essay Competiton 2025

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Op Sindoor 2.0: Why & How India Must Prepare for the Next Round?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • DefAI: Cyber & AI Frontiers for Defence | The Third Cyber Workshop from CLAWS & HACKTIFY

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Pahalgam Response: Why India Must Fight Smart?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

About us

CLAWS

The Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS), New Delhi, India is an independent think tank on strategic studies and land warfare. The mandate of CLAWS covers national security issues, conventional military operations and sub-conventional warfare.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Articles
  • Autumn 2019
  • Autumn 2020
  • Books
  • CLAWS Focus
  • CLAWS Journal
  • Essay
  • Events
  • External Publications
  • FMMEC
  • Intern Articles
  • Issue Briefs
  • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
  • Manekshaw Papers
  • Newsletter
  • Round Tables
  • Scholar Warrior
  • Seminars
  • Uncategorized
  • Web Updates
  • Winter 2019
  • YouTube Podcast

Recent News

Unmasking LAMEHUG: APT28’s AI-Fuelled Cyber Offensive Against Ukraine

Unmasking LAMEHUG: APT28’s AI-Fuelled Cyber Offensive Against Ukraine

July 21, 2025
Russia Recognises Taliban: A New Era of Cooperation

Russia Recognises Taliban: A New Era of Cooperation

July 16, 2025
  • Site Map
  • Tenders
  • Advertise With Us
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Other Think Tanks

© 2008-2024 Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS).

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Director General
    • Additional Director General
    • Jottings by Director General Emiritus
    • CLAWS Membership
    • Faculty
  • Publication
    • Web Articles
    • Issue Briefs
    • Manekshaw Papers
    • Newsletter
    • CLAWS Journal
    • Scholar Warrior
    • Books
    • Essay
    • Intern Articles
    • External Publications
  • Research Areas
    • Global & Regional Security
      • China
      • Pakistan
      • Afghanistan
      • South Asia
      • Indo Pacific
      • US, EU & Russia
      • MENA
      • CAR
    • National Security
      • National Security Strategy
      • Nuclear Deterrence
      • Non Traditional Threats
      • Intelligence
      • Terrorism & Internal Security
      • Grey Z & IW
      • Security Laws
    • Military Studies
      • Military Doctrine
      • Military Strategy
      • Peace Keeping Ops
      • Military History
      • Military Logistics
      • Out of Area Contingency Ops
      • Leadership
    • Military Technology & Defence Acquisition
      • Military Technology
      • Defence Acqn
      • Budgets & Finance
      • Defence Infrastructure
      • Human Resources
    • Multi Domain Studies
      • Jointmanship & Integration
      • Space
      • Cyber
      • Spl Operations
      • Energy & Environment
      • Defence Eco System
      • Defence Diplomacy
      • HADR
  • Web Archive
  • Events
    • Seminars
    • Webinars/RTD
  • PROMEX
  • University Cell
    • About The Initiative
    • Admission: Eligibility and Procedure
    • Important Information
    • Administration
    • Guides | Supervisors
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2008-2024 Centre for Land Warfare Studies (CLAWS).